1. Padron 45th - This stays at number one for me, I have only smoked one, but it was an amazing smoke and deserves this year's Cigar of the Year.
2. Cohiba Siglo Tubo (Cuban) - I have also smoked one of these, and I agree with Chris, an over rated cigar, tasty, just does not meet a number 2 standard, I put Nestor Miranda here as well, reasonably priced, and an excellent full flavored medium body cigar!
3. My Father - I have smoked this cigar, a friend gave me one, it wasn't bad, but I have to put the La Flor Double Press at number 3, it is another brilliant smoke put out by La Flor Dominicana!
4. Diamond Crown Maximus - This cigar is okay, just didn't do it for my palate, I have to put Frank LLaneza by Altadis in the number 4 slot, It is an excellent full bodied smoke, with an incredible amount of flavor.
5. Oliva V - I agree with Chris on this one, leave the V at number 5, it has been an amazing smoke since it came out and is a great cigar. I look at this as another great standby to go back to one I used to regularly smoke!